Coppice renovation of a mixed native farmland hedge: what the hollow boundary looks like before, what it looks like three seasons on, and the four stages in between
The mixed native hedges along field boundaries around Staple, Shatterling and the Ash Road corridor are mostly hawthorn (Crataegus monogyna) with blackthorn (Prunus spinosa) and field maple (Acer campestre) running through, sometimes hazel or dogwood in the mix where the hedge was planted on a proper native programme. In their original state these are excellent hedges: thick from ground level, full of food and cover for the farmland birds this part of Dover District still holds, genuinely stock-proof. The problem is what twenty or thirty years of annual flail cutting does to them. The cutting head removes everything that reaches the set height. It does nothing to encourage new growth from the base. Season by season the base of the hedge hollows out, the canopy thickens into an arch overhead, and the structural density that makes a farmland hedge useful, to the farmer, to the yellowhammer, to the linnet, disappears. Coppice renovation is the technique that reverses this. It is not the same as the one-side-at-a-time renovation approach used on beech or yew garden hedges, and it produces a different kind of result.
Before
A mixed native field-boundary hedge around Staple or Shatterling that has been flail-cut every year for fifteen to twenty years typically reads well from a distance. At 2 to 2.5 metres tall with an unbroken canopy line along the field edge, it looks like a functioning hedge from the road or from a tractor cab. The problem shows from standing in the field and looking into the base. The lowest 50 to 80 centimetres are completely bare: a row of thickened grey stems, the field visible through them at ground level, no foliage below about knee height. The main stems at the base are often 5 to 12 centimetres in diameter, barked over decades of growth, carrying no live shoots at all below the point where the flail has been passing each year. All the active growth sits in the upper canopy, pushed further up each season as the hedge responds to the annual cut by producing new material from the top. Blackthorn in this state sends up the occasional sucker from its roots, which the flail removes the following season before it can do anything. Field maple in a hedge maintained this way concentrates all its growth in the upper canopy and produces nothing at the base. Hawthorn, similarly, has dense tip-growth but bare lower stems. The hedge as a whole is hollow: structurally sound at the top, empty at the bottom. It does not stop livestock reliably. It does not give farmland birds the ground-level cover they need to nest. The yellowhammer, which needs a hedge thick from the ground up to nest in this part of east Kent, has nothing to use in it.
After
Three growing seasons after a coppice renovation, a mixed native hedge of hawthorn, blackthorn and field maple that was a 2.5-metre arching canopy over bare lower stems is typically between 1.5 and 1.8 metres tall, multi-stem and bushy from ground level, with a tighter and more varied structure than the annually-cut hedge it replaced. The blackthorn in the mix usually provides the densest ground-level cover within the first season: it produces aggressive root suckers the moment the above-ground competition is removed, creating a dense thicket from soil level within twelve to eighteen months of the coppice cut. The hawthorn stumps push strong shoots from dormant buds at the cut surface, and by the end of the second growing season these are branching out to form lateral structure. The field maple produces vigorous stool growth that can reach 60 to 90 centimetres in the first season on the heavier loam soils of this part of east Kent, and by season three it is contributing lateral branches at mid-hedge height. The hedge that was hollow from knee level down now has growth from soil level up. It is not yet back to full managed hedge height and will need two or three more years of careful annual trimming to establish the shape it will hold, but its structure as a wildlife and boundary feature is already much better than the over-clipped canopy arch of before.
Stage 1: the assessment and the coppice decision (autumn, year one)
The first question is whether coppice renovation is actually the right technique for this hedge. It is not always the right answer for an overgrown or neglected hedge. The one-side-at-a-time renovation approach, where you cut one face hard and leave the other untouched, is a better choice for single-species hedges of beech, hornbeam or yew that have been shaped as garden or estate boundary features. Those hedges have a different structure and a different purpose: they are managed for formal appearance, and cutting them hard to base-level stumps is unnecessary and disruptive. For a mixed native farmland boundary hedge that has been routinely flail-cut and has lost its base structure, coppice renovation is the appropriate intervention because the existing structure above the base has no value worth preserving. The whole point is to remove it and start again from the root system.
I walk the hedge in autumn, before any cutting begins. I am looking at three things. First, what species are actually present. A hedge identified as hawthorn often has blackthorn running through it, particularly in farmland situations in east Kent where blackthorn colonises from adjacent areas. Field maple is often present in hedges alongside Ash, Wingham and Woodnesborough where the original hedgerow planting used a native mix. Elder is sometimes present and is a slightly different case: it coppices readily but can dominate the recovery if it is not managed, because it grows faster than hawthorn or field maple from the same base. Where elder makes up a significant proportion of the hedge I plan to address it separately rather than letting it overwhelm the slower-growing species in the first season. Second, I check whether there are any hedgerow trees within the hedge boundary. A standard oak, ash or field maple that has been allowed to grow to tree height is not part of the coppice programme. Trees of this kind are managed separately, and if the address falls within a conservation area (Staple itself has no conservation area, but Ash, Wingham and Goodnestone do) a section 211 notice to Dover District Council would be required before work on any tree over 75 millimetres stem diameter at 1.5 metres. Coppicing a hedgerow (the shrubby component, below tree height) in a conservation area is treated differently from working on individual trees, but it is worth confirming the position before the job starts on any address I am not already familiar with. Third, I check the root system condition at the base of the main hedge species. Scratching the bark of a thick old stem at the base with a fingernail should reveal green living tissue beneath. A stem that is dry and brown at the base has died, and coppicing dead roots produces nothing. In a genuinely healthy hedge that has simply been over-cut from above, the base stems are almost always alive: the hollowness at the base is caused by light exclusion, not stem death, and restoring light through the coppice cut is enough to reactivate dormant buds and root-sucker production.
The timing for the coppice cut is November through to the end of January. Coppicing in full winter dormancy, when the root system has pulled its stored energy down out of the stems and is resting, gives the plant the best conditions to push strong new growth in the following spring. Cutting later than mid-February runs into the risk of competition with the early growing season, and cutting after the end of February runs directly into the nesting-season legal window.
Nesting season and the coppice cut: why timing is non-negotiable
Coppicing a farmland hedge is more disruptive to nesting habitat than a routine trimming cut, because it removes the entire above-ground structure. This makes the timing restriction under the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 especially important. Section 1 makes it an offence to intentionally damage or destroy an active nest; the penalty on conviction is up to six months in prison, an unlimited fine, or both. The practical nesting season applied in England runs 1 March to 31 August, and in a mild east Kent spring early nesters such as blackbirds and song thrushes can begin nesting in late February. I aim to complete all coppice cuts by the end of January to be clear of any overlap with early nesting. Finishing by the end of January also means the cut stumps have the full February rest period before active growth begins in March, which is good for the plant. If a job is delayed into February and I am not certain it can finish before the end of the month, I defer it to the following winter entirely. There is no justification for rushed late-February coppicing on a hedge that holds nesting birds: the farmland hedges of east Kent carry yellowhammer, linnet and other declining species, and a nest destroyed during coppicing is a criminal offence, not a minor regulatory risk.
Stage 2: the coppice cut (winter, year one)
The cut itself is straightforward in method, though physically demanding on a long hedge run. I cut all stems to stumps 15 to 25 centimetres above soil level, leaving the cut on a slight bevel so rainwater runs off the cut face rather than pooling on it. The stump height matters: cutting flush to the ground removes the dormant bud sites just above the root collar that are the most reliable source of new shoots. Leaving 15 to 25 centimetres of stump gives the plant more bud sites to push from and makes the regrowth phase more vigorous in the first season.
For stems up to about 5 centimetres in diameter a sharp bowsaw is the right tool: clean cuts, no splitting of the stump. For main stems between 5 and 12 centimetres a small chainsaw with a sharp chain is faster and cleaner than a bowsaw. For the larger old base stems of a hawthorn that has been building mass for twenty years, you may be dealing with wood 12 to 15 centimetres across: this cuts cleanly with a chainsaw. The cut surface should be clean, not torn or split. A ragged cut surface on a hawthorn or blackthorn stump provides an entry point for fungal infection, particularly Neonectria canker, which is the main risk in leaving an untidy cut in the stump.
Blackthorn demands respect for its thorns throughout this work. The thorns are stiff, brittle and break off at the tip when they penetrate gloves or skin, making removal difficult. Thick thorn-proof gloves are essential for blackthorn coppice work. Eye protection is worth wearing throughout any blackthorn cutting, since stems spring back unpredictably as they are cut. I wear a face visor rather than just safety glasses on any blackthorn-heavy section of hedge.
The cut material comes off as a mixture of thin hedge trimmings and thicker old stems. The thin material can be chipped and spread along the base of the cut hedge as a temporary mulch, which holds moisture over the root zone in the first season and is a small benefit to the recovery. The thicker main stems are generally too woody to chip without a substantial chipper and are typically stacked in a brash pile at the field margin, where they provide cover for invertebrates and small mammals through the following summer. If the hedge runs alongside a road or a public footpath, all cut material goes off-site: a brash pile on a verge or footpath is not appropriate.
After cutting, the hedge looks severe: a row of pale cut stumps at 15 to 25 centimetres, bare on all sides, no green at all from what was a 2.5-metre canopy. This is the correct result and is not a sign of damage. The severity of appearance at this stage is one of the reasons some landowners hesitate to authorise a coppice renovation. I usually photograph the stumps immediately after cutting, so there is a clear record of what the cut stumps looked like before the first growing season begins.
Stage 3: the first growing season (spring-summer, year one)
By late February, even before the official start of spring, the blackthorn stumps often show the first signs of response: small pale buds swelling at the cut surface and along the length of the stump. Blackthorn's root sucker production begins earlier than any of the other main farmland hedge species: by March there are often new shoots pushing up from the root system at some distance from the original stumps, in places where the roots have spread laterally. This sucker production is what makes blackthorn so useful in a coppice renovation: it fills the basal zone from the ground up without depending solely on the stumps.
By April the hawthorn stumps are producing their first flush of new shoots from the cut surface. Hawthorn carries dormant buds in the bark below the cut and pushes them into growth strongly once the light and warmth of spring arrive. By late April a well-established hawthorn stump is typically carrying 10 to 15 new shoots, each 15 to 30 centimetres long, clustered around the cut surface. These are thin, flexible and green: they look nothing like the woody structure they will eventually become.
By June the field maple stumps are well into their recovery. Field maple is a vigorous resprouter and on the heavier farmland loam of this part of east Kent, which holds moisture through what can be dry east Kent summers, it can produce 60 to 80 centimetres of new shoot growth by the end of the first season. The stool growth is multi-stem from the base: multiple shoots from each stump rather than a single dominant leader, which is exactly what is needed for hedge base structure.
Through July and August the hedge looks low but dense in the basal zone: a mass of new green growth between 40 and 90 centimetres tall, thick at the base, beginning to close over the ground between the stumps. At this stage I do not cut it. The plant is putting all its energy into the new growth and every leaf it has built is working to refill the root system's reserves. Cutting at this stage would set the recovery back significantly. The only intervention I make in the first growing season is to check for deer and rabbit browsing. In the farmland around Staple and Shatterling the muntjac and roe deer pressure on young hedge growth is real: new shoots at 30 to 50 centimetres are at exactly the height deer browse most readily, and a hedge recovering from coppice with its new growth browsed back each time it reaches browsable height will struggle to establish. Where deer pressure is significant I recommend a temporary fence along the cut hedge face for the first two seasons, which is the most practical solution even if it looks incongruous.
Stage 4: year two and the start of hedge structure
Into the second growing season the established shoots from year one thicken at the base and branch laterally. Hawthorn shoots that were 60 to 80 centimetres at the end of year one carry small side branches by year two, beginning to build the interlocked structure that makes a farmland hedge difficult to push through. Blackthorn sucker growth from year one, unchecked, has typically reached 80 to 120 centimetres by the end of year two: not yet at hedge height but already dense and thorny at the base. Field maple year-two growth from established stools can reach 100 to 130 centimetres on good soil.
By the end of year two the hedge has gone from a row of bare stumps to a bushy thicket between 80 centimetres and 1.3 metres tall, varying by species and soil. It is not yet at hedge height and it does not have the formal battered profile of a trimmed hedge. What it does have is structure at ground level that the annually-flail-cut hedge entirely lacked.
The question in year two is whether to start any formative trimming. My general approach on a farmland hedge recovering from coppice is to leave year two alone, just as year one was left. The plants are still building root reserves, and cutting into the new growth before the structure is established achieves nothing except stress. In year three I begin light formative trimming: removing the tallest and most dominant stems to encourage lateral branching in the remaining growth, beginning to establish the batter profile (wider at the base, narrower at the top) that a well-maintained farmland hedge maintains. By year four the hedge is typically at 1.5 to 1.8 metres, covered from the ground up, and ready to go onto a proper rotational cutting cycle: one cut every two to three years at gradually rising height, rather than the annual flail that hollowed it out in the first place.
How coppicing compares to other renovation approaches for east Kent farmland hedges
The one-side-at-a-time renovation approach I use on beech, yew, privet and hornbeam garden hedges does not apply to a mixed native farmland hedge in the way described here. Those approaches maintain continuous foliage on the untouched face to support the plant while the cut face recovers. For a farmland hedge whose entire base structure has been lost, there is no face worth preserving: the untouched canopy that annual flail cutting has produced is the problem, not a resource to be protected.
Hedge laying is the other widely used renovation technique for farmland hedges and shares coppicing's ability to restore base structure. Laying is the better choice for a hedge that still has some basal growth worth working with: where individual stems are still relatively young and flexible enough to be pleached (partially cut through and bent over), laying produces a denser and more immediate result than coppicing. Coppicing is the better choice for a hedge where the base stems are too old and thick to be laid without splitting: stems over about 10 centimetres in diameter are difficult to lay without structural damage, and a hawthorn or field maple hedge with 20-year-old main stems at 10 to 15 centimetres is better coppiced than attempted as a lay. The right choice depends on what the hedge actually looks like at the base.
The one approach that does not restore base structure in a mixed native farmland hedge is continuing to flail it annually, perhaps at a slightly lower height. Annual flailing perpetuates the very mechanism that created the hollow base structure: new growth from the existing stems, removed each year before it can extend downward, with no regeneration from the base. Reducing the cutting height by 30 centimetres each year and hoping the base will fill in does not work on an established hawthorn-blackthorn hedge. The base is hollow because of decades of light exclusion from the canopy. Only removing the canopy restores the light to the base stumps and root system that drives recovery.
Related guides
- Renovating an overgrown hazel hedge: before, the three-stage coppice reset, and the recovered boundary after
- Renovating an overgrown blackthorn hedge: before, three stages, and the productive boundary after
- Farmland boundary hedge management: from annual-cut rut to rotational health
- Renovating an overgrown bullace (wild plum) hedge: four stages from a tall, gappy boundary back to a working fruiting hedge
Got a farmland boundary hedge that has gone hollow at the base?
A photograph showing the base of the hedge from the field side, with a rough note of the stem diameters at base level, tells me most of what I need to know. Send it to hello@staplehedges.co.uk or call 07763 100 477. I can tell you whether coppice renovation, laying, or something else is the right approach for the hedge you have, and what the job is likely to cost across the recovery years.
Sources: "Management for Healthy Hedgerows" Part 1, dir. Tom Hartwell, featuring PTES Key Habitats Officer Megan Gimber (Woodlands.co.uk, February 2025; YouTube: youtu.be/_UV3cUE5QDc). PTES Hedgelink Hedge Management Cycle guide (ptes.org) covers cutting frequency, the coppicing/rejuvenation approach, and the importance of not cutting every year. RHS "Hedges: renovation" (rhs.org.uk/plants/types/hedges/renovation) confirms hawthorn, blackthorn and field maple tolerate renovation from old wood; notes hawthorn as best species for laying with blackthorn and field maple also suitable. Ashridge Trees field maple hedge page (ashridgetrees.co.uk) confirms field maple is very tolerant of hard pruning, preferred winter timing. Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, section 1; nesting-season timing. Hedgerow Regulations 1997 (where applicable to boundary removal; not applicable to coppice renovation of an existing hedge).